On October 26, Rep. Lamar Smith introduced the Stopping Online Piracy Act (H.R. 3261), also called the Enforcing and Protecting American Rights Against Sites Intent on Theft and Exploitation Act (E-PARASTE Act.) H.R. 3261 is the House version of the Senatory Leahy’s PROTECT-IP Act, which goes after sites that host infringing content by taking down domain names and requiring service providers, including search engines, advertisers, and online payment processors, to stop doing business with them.
The scope of websites that could be affected by H.R. 3621 bill is larger than that of the Senate bill. While the Senate bill applies to sites “dedicated to infringing activities,” the house bill applies to sites that “facilitate” infringement.” A site may be considered to facilitate infringement if (among other reasons) it takes actions to “avoid confirming a high probability of infringement,” – a provision which civil society groups warned may force service providers to monitor websites that contain user generated content.
H.R. 3261 also includes a House version of Sen. Klobuchar’s bill to make unauthorized web streaming of copyrighted content a felony with a possible penalty of up to 5 years in prison.
The House Judiciary Committee will hold a hearing on the bill on November 16.
Comments from Civil Society
- Sherwin Siy for Public Knowledge. “House Version of Rogue Websites Bill Adds DMCA Bypass, Penalties for DNS Workarounds.” October 26, 2011.
Excerpt: SOPA is significantly worse than its Senate cousin. This isn’t just because it uses more expansive definitions or broader language; it makes fundamental changes to who faces liability for copyright infringement.
- Corynne McSherry for the Electronic Frontier Foundation. “Disastrous IP Legislation Is Back – And It’s Worse than Ever.” October 26, 2011.
Excerpt: The bill seems mainly aimed at creating an end-run around the DMCA safe harbors. Instead of complying with the DMCA, a copyright owner may now be able to use these new provisions to effectively shut down a site by cutting off access to its domain name, its search engine hits, its ads, and its other financing, even if the safe harbors would apply.”
- David Sohn for the Center for Democracy and Technology. “House Copyright Bill Casts Dangerously Broad Net.” October 27, 2011.
Excerpt: Narrowly targeting the true bad actors is one thing. Imposing new costs and risks on anyone providing online communications tools would seriously undermine online innovation and free expression.
- Juliana Gruenwald for the National Journal. House Judiciary Leaders Produce Online Piracy Bill. October 27, 2011.
- Gautham Nagesh for The Hill. House members unveil Stop Online Piracy Act. October 26, 2011.
- Mike Masnic for TechDirt. PROTECT IP Renamed E-PARASITES Act; Would Create The Great Firewall Of America. October 26, 2011.